Do Not Say We Have Nothing by Madeleine Thien

Do Not Say We Have Nothing

Madeleine Thien

A sweeping novel, that is both a family saga and a historical overview of the cultural revolution in China. Central to the story are a group of classical musicians, and music intertwines everything in the book which is poetic and beautiful at times, yet also, inevitably, violent and painful. Stories within stories, and flashbacks, make this confusing at times, yet it’s an unsettling epic well worth reading.


They were sitting as near to one another as possible without touching. The music filled the space between them, its motifs turning over as if the composer had no conclusion, only movements that came around in a spiral, rising each time to a new beginning but an old place.

  • Startling Moon by Liu Hong
  • Three sisters by Bi Feiyu

Books with similar mood

Three Day Road

Joseph Boyden

Fragrant Harbour

John Lanchester

The Constant Gardener

John Le Carre

The History of Bees

Maja Lunde

The Memory Stones

Caroline Brothers

All the Light We Cannot See

Anthony Doerr

The Fishermen

Chigozie Obioma

The Blindman's Garden

Nadeem Aslam

Altered Land

Jules Hardy

The Poet's Wife

Judith Allnatt

The End of Innocence

Moni Mohsin


Marilynne Robinson

The Snow Child

Eowyn Ivey


Wu Ming

American Rust

Philipp Meyer

We That Are Young

Preti Taneja

Beneath the Lion's Gaze

Maaza Mengiste


Nick Stafford

Man Gone Down

Michael Thomas

Echoes from the Dead

Johan Theorin

The Fortress

Mesa Selimovic

The Prophets of Eternal Fjord

Kim Leine

Song for an Approaching Storm

Peter Fröberg Idling

The Big Music

Kirsty Gunn

The Visiting Angel

Paul Wilson

Under Fishbone Clouds

Sam Meekings

Tell it to the Bees

Fiona Shaw

In the Distance

Hernan Diaz

War and Turpentine

Stefan Hertmans

The Bamboo Stalk

Saud Alsanousi

The Architect's Apprentice

Elif Shafak


Jane Rusbridge

This is Paradise

Will Eaves

A Death in the Family

Karl Ove Knausgaard

Running the Rift

Naomi Benaron

The Lost Word

Oya Baydar

Underground Time

Delphine de Vigan


Roger Hubank

The Parisian

Isabella Hammad

The Last Pilot

Benjamin Johncock


Nicholas Mainieri

Life After Life

Kate Atkinson

Journey to the Stone Country

Alex Miller

The Big Snow

David Park

Family Matters

Rohinton Mistry

Fugitive Pieces

Anne Michaels

Nightingale Point

Luan Goldie


Négar Djavadi