Say Say Say by Lila Savage

Say Say Say

Lila Savage

This moving and reflective story, though not driven by plot, action or dialogue, gives the reader much to contemplate. Ella is not a character I particularly warmed to, but admired for her honest approach to her role - she knows she falls short and strives to be better. Really nails the dynamics of the relationship between a carer and the family she has been hired to help.


Ella coaxed into being an idea of who Jill was, who she had been; she sculpted it inventively from the rough material she was given. This was necessary, because Ella felt the need to love Jill, and it was easier to love a person. She tried to imagine the life Jill and Bryn had shared before the accident (seldom referenced, never elaborated on - Ella never heard exactly what had happened) that had changed their lives so abruptly.

  • The Carer by Deborah Moggach
  • The Bear Came Over the Mountain by Alice Munro
  • The Whole Day Through by Patrick Gale

Books with similar mood

The Sky is Changing

Zoe Jenny

Fifty Days

Sarah Quigley

Crow Lake

Mary Lawson

Lyrics Alley

Leila Aboulela

Villa America

Liza Klaussmann

Old Filth

Jane Gardam

A Ship Made of Paper

Scott Spencer

James Miranda Barry

Patricia Duncker

The Forms of Water

Andrea Barrett

The Lowland

Jhumpa Lahiri

The Bookman's Tale

Charlie Lovett

The Forrests

Emily Perkins

In the Falling Snow

Caryl Phillips

Now You See Him

Eli Gottlieb

Winter Under Water

James Hopkin

Canvey Island

James Runcie

Something Rising (light and swift)

Haven Kimmel

A Crying Shame

Renate Dorrestein

The Painter

Will Davenport

No Great Mischief

Alistair MacLeod


Nigel Pickard

The Cypriot

Andreas Koumi

The Paris Wife

Paula McLain

The Tenth Muse

Catherine Chung

A Kind of Freedom

Margaret Wilkerson Sexton

The Bones of Grace

Tahmima Anam

You Came Back

Christopher Coake

The Cookbook Collector

Allegra Goodman

The Princess of Mantua

Marie Ferranti

Small Crimes in an Age of Abundance

Matthew Kneale

Give Us This Day

Jonathan Tulloch

The Cairo House

Samia Serageldin

Eva Moves the Furniture

Margot Livesey


Eduardo Berti


Kirsty Gunn

The Cryptographer

Tobias Hill

Upstairs in the Tent

Cynthia Rogerson

Hotel of the Saints

Ursula Hegi

Five Quarters of the Orange

Joanne Harris

Accidents in the Home

Tessa Hadley

Some Prefer Nettles

Junichiro Tanizaki

The Funeral Party

Ludmilla Ulitskaya

Lunatics, Lovers and Poets

Daniel Hahn & Margarita Valencia (eds)

Last Night on Earth

Kevin Maher


Oona Frawley

Night Waking

Sarah Moss

The Scents of Marie-Claire

Habib Selmi


Deborah Robertson

About Grace

Anthony Doerr