Passing Under Heaven by Justin Hill

Passing Under Heaven

Justin Hill

I found it hard to relate to the characters in this 9th century Chinese love story. Lily is a tragic heroine from the outset yet I found it difficult to care as we follow her downward path from orphan to concubine to celebrated courtesan to prisoner. Maybe the setting was just too distant for me to empathise. However, it is always interesting to visit the temples, pavilions, lakes and snow-capped mountains of such a different time and place. I would like to have heard more about the lives of the ordinary charcters as so many of them were memorable and unusual. Granny Pig is a fine comic creation.


After Minister Li had left, Lily lay down, but instead of sleep she felt a terrible fear, as if she teetered on the edge of a vast chasm. No tears left, she told herself, as she lay on her back and stared into the darkness, remembered an image of twirling red dragons, sucking each other down.

'Lily!Lily?' Minister Li's voice shouted over the wall. 'I have a sedan here!'
But his voice seemed to come from very far away and long ago. He wants to cage you again, the voice in her head said. Do not open the door. Do not let him cage you. Do not, do not, do not. She could not bring herself to open the door. The good memories were enough, she told herself, as if only so much happiness was apportioned to each man's lifetime.

'I want to take you home!' For a moment Minister Li's voice was clear and sharp.
Lily's lower lip trembled.
Do not, the voice reminded her.

  • The Girl Who Played Go by Shan Sa
  • Farewell my Concubine - the film

Books with similar mood


Paule Marshall

The Immigrant

Manju Kapur

Once Upon a Time in England

Helen Walsh

The Map of Love

Ahdaf Soueif

The Romantic

Barbara Gowdy

The Saving Graces

Patricia Gaffney

Biography of Desire

Mary Dorcey

Variable Stars

Christina Koning

Undiscovered Country

Christina Koning

Ellie and the Shadow Man

Maurice Gee

Days of Grace

Catherine Hall

A Mad and Wonderful Thing

Mark Mulholland


Jim Crace


Alex Miller

The Outcast

Sadie Jones

The Half Brother

Lars Saabye Christensen

Sweetness in the Belly

Camilla Gibb

The Round House

Louise Erdrich

Spelling Mississippi

Marnie Woodrow

After You'd Gone

Maggie O'Farrell

Crimson China

Betsy Tobin

In the Full Light of the Sun

Clare Clark

The Starboard Sea

Amber Dermont

The Paper Lovers

Gerard Woodward

Carry The One

Carol Anshaw

Falling Sideways

Thomas E Kennedy

Before I Forget

Andre Brink


Andrew O'Hagan

Killer Tune

Dreda Say Mitchell

Snow in May

Kseniya Melnik


Iain Banks

Salvage the Bones

Jesmyn Ward

Black Hole

Charles Burns

Capability's Eden

Diana Saville

Larger than Life

Adele Parks


Alison Miller

The Moor's Account

Laila Lalami


Ben Brooks

The Ask

Sam Lipsyte

The Northern Clemency

Philip Hensher

You Will Be Safe Here

Damian Barr

Saying Nothing

Catherine Broughton

A Walk Across the Sun

Corban Addison

The White Woman on the Green Bicycle

Monique Roffey

The Glass Room

Simon Mawer

State of the Union

Douglas Kennedy

The Colour

Rose Tremain

One for my Baby

Tony Parsons

Half in Love

Justin Cartwright